The Cake & Cookie shop was purchased in 1980 by William
and Augusta Fehn. It was a family affair, with all four
children working side by side with their parents. Heidi and
Debbie managed the store, while “Brother Bill” and Kathy
went on to study at the prestigious Culinary Institute of
America. Upon graduation, Billy moved to Germany to
become a Master Pastry Chef, and Kathy became a Pastry
Chef at the famed Waldorf Astoria in NYC. After several
years at the Waldorf, Kathy returned home to the
Cake & Cookie Shop.

After 40 years in the industry, Bill and Gussie decided it
was time to retire. With the business up for sale,
Heidi & Kathy decided that the family business was too
precious to be sold. After years of starting work in the
wee hours of the morning, weekends & holidays;
crazy as it sounds, Kathy & Heidi became the proud
new owners.

In March 2004, after major renovations, “Fehn’s Cake &
Cookie Shop” was in business. In keeping with family
tradition, Kathy creates culinary delights, while Heidi
manages the day to day operations.

We are a full line bakery with everything from breads to
wedding cakes. After many requests from the businesses
we supply and our customers who have relocated from the
neighborhood, our delicious butter cookies can now be
shipped throughout the United States. Order for yourself
or send as a great gift. We know you won’t be



Fehn's Cake & Cookie Shop
3649 Merrick Road
Seaford, NY 11783

Hours of Operation
Tuesday – Thursday 6:30 am – 7:00 pm
Friday & Saturday 6:00 – 7:00 pm
Sunday 6:00 am – 6:00 pm
Closed Mondays

Phone: 516-785-CAKE (2253)

Visit our Website


Whether you are shopping for the holidays or for a great
tasting treat, you have come to the right place. Purchase
your cookies and gift certificates from our online shop or
stop in our Seaford, Long Island location.